Sunday, May 15, 2011

Why Orthodox Christians Don't Participate in Joint Worship and Prayer Services


Why Orthodox Christians Don’t Participate in Joint Worship and Prayer Services with Various Denominations or Religious Bodies


Introduction
     Christians from the various denominations cannot understand why Orthodox Christians do not participate in joint worship or prayer services such as Easter sunrise services, Thanksgiving Day services, National Day of prayer or any other worship/prayer services.  The very idea that some would consider it wrong to participate in joint worship and prayer with others is a concept that is totally foreign and baffling to most in American Christianity. 

     For the purposes of this paper, the groups who find the Orthodox view on this subject to be strange or even offensive will be grouped together and referred to simply as American Christianity.  American Christianity in this context includes most denominations and those who call themselves non or inter-denominational.   All of these groups hold a form of the Christian Faith that developed in and grew out of the Western/American experience and is unique to Western/American Christianity.

     American Christianity stands in sharp contrast to the Orthodox Christian Faith, and herein lies the problem. Most in American Christianity cannot understand why joint worship is a problem precisely because they do not understand the great difference and divide between them and the Orthodox Faith.   Some may perceive Orthodoxy, if they know of it at all, as just one more denomination among many that shares a common understanding on the basics but exists as a separate denomination because of differences that really don’t matter.  From an Orthodox perspective nothing could be further from the truth.  American Christianity and Orthodoxy are two very different understandings and expressions of the Christian Faith; not just in a few externals and customs but in the very essence of what is confessed and believed about the Christian Faith.

     If a Christian who lived, let’s say in Antioch, Jerusalem or Alexandria in the 3rd, 4th or 5th centuries could suddenly appear in America today he could enter any Orthodox Church for a Sunday service and apart from a language barrier he would be right at home.  He would recognize the worship with all its forms and parts and the Faith confessed as the same he had known back then.   But if he entered a typical church of American Christianity, he would encounter a form of worship and an understanding of the Christian Faith that would be unrecognizable to him.   To be sure, most in American Christianity don’t see why this is a problem.  They contend the Church has to adapt to the culture and that’s why American Christianity is so different from something out of the past.   But this is simply one more indication of the great difference and divide that exists between the Orthodox Faith and American Christianity, as we shall see.

     What is it about the Orthodox Faith that is so different and unknown to American Christianity?   How is it more than just a difference in a few non-essential externals?  Why does Orthodoxy refuse to change with times, fads and movements?  And why do these differences pose a problem for joint worship and prayer from the Orthodox perspective?

     The essential differences between the Orthodox Christian Faith and American Christianity can be grouped under three broad headings:
·    Different foundations
·    Different content
·    Different conclusions

Different Foundations
     Foundation has to do with what we stand on, the source of our authority and that on which we base our existence.  Our understanding of how we came to be – the foundation we are built upon, ultimately determines our beliefs and our practices.

The Foundation of American Christianity
     American Christianity claims the Christian Faith as their foundation, to be sure, but it is as each one or each group understands that Faith according to their interpretation of the Bible.  Everything goes back to the Bible and everything is drawn from the Bible.  The Bible is claimed as the manual, the source and guide for all that is believed and followed in American Christianity.  This is the heritage of the Reformation in Europe in the 16th century and of the Restoration Movement and the Great Awakening in the 19th century in America.  A description or explanation of these movements is beyond the scope of this paper.  Suffice it to say, American Christianity is the product of these movements that based the Christian Faith and the various churches on Scripture alone.   These movements soundly rejected any source as authoritative for determining their faith and practice except the Bible.  All the teachings of the early Church Fathers, the Church Councils through the centuries and the consensus of the early Church were rejected as sources for determining the beliefs and practices of the Christian Faith.   Nothing could be taught or believed as essential to the Christian Faith unless it was taught in the Bible.  American Christianity claims the Bible to be its sole foundation – that from which all of its beliefs and practices are drawn or based upon.  This is called sola scriptura, from the Latin for scripture alone.

     The Orthodox Christian Faith rejects the teaching of sola scriptura as false and misleading, believing it results in an understanding of the Christian Faith that is very different from the historical Faith, both as to its content and its practices. 

     Before explaining the contrasting foundation of the Orthodox Faith, it would be helpful to understand some of the problems the Orthodox Church has with sola scriptura and why we believe it has produced a form of the Christian Faith that is erroneous in many of its parts and therefore unacceptable.    

     The first problem is that the concept of sola scriptura is a late development.  This doctrine was taught by certain reformers who created their own church some 1500 years after the Church began.  In fact, the Church existed almost 400 years before there was anything close to the New Testament as we have it today.  For almost twice as long as America has been a nation, the Church existed without knowing which books that now comprise the New Testament were authentic and which were not. There was no clearly defined New Testament until the 4th century.  Even then people did not have copies of the Bible until hundreds of years later with the invention of the printing press.  People did not carry Bibles to church in the first century and Saint Paul did not preach from a Bible.  From this it should be clear that the Church did not grow out of the Bible and was not based on the Bible.  The Bible grew out of and was based on what the Church already believed and practiced.  The Bible did not give us the Church.  The Church gave us the Bible.  The Bible does not interpret the Church. The Church interprets the Bible.  These are crucial distinctions that result in very different Faiths.

     The second problem with sola scriptura is that there is no such thing.  It is a false construct.  The Bible begs interpretation.  It does not interpret itself.  It is open to many different meanings and understandings.  This is why there are thousands of denominations all claiming to be based on the Bible.   The fact that the Bible needs interpretation is why there are preachers preaching, teachers teaching, Bible studies studying and authors writing thousands of books and commentaries to explain the meaning of the Bible.  If it were self-interpreting, there would be no need for all the attempts to interpret it and there would not be numerous interpretations and explanations.

     The fact is that all of American Christianity is built, not on the Bible alone, but on someone’s interpretation of the Bible.  Every denomination or group has its own tradition that determines its interpretation of the Bible. Each denomination or group is based on a preacher’s interpretation or that of the denominational founder or leaders. If you are a Lutheran, your religion was founded by Martin Luther, an ex-monk of the Catholic Church, in the year 1517. If you belong to the Church of England, your religion was founded by King Henry VIII in the year 1534 because the Pope would not grant him a divorce with the right to re-marry. If you are a Presbyterian, your religion was founded by John Knox in Scotland in the year 1560. If you are a Congregationalist, your religion was originated by Robert Brown in Holland in 1582. If you are Protestant Episcopalian, your religion was an offshoot of the Church of England, founded by Samuel Seabury in the American colonies in the 17th century. If you are a Baptist, you owe the tenets of your religion to John Smyth, who launched it in Amsterdam in 1606. If you are of the Dutch Reformed Church, you recognize Michelis Jones as founder because he originated your religion in New York in 1628. If you are a Methodist, your religion was founded by John and Charles Wesley in England in 1774. If you are a Mormon (Latter Day Saints), Joseph Smith started your religion in Palmyra, New York, in 1829. If you worship with the Salvation Army, your sect began with William Booth in London in 1865. If you are Christian Scientist, you look to 1879 as the year in which your religion was born and to Mary Baker Eddy as its founder.

     If you belong to one of the religious organizations known as Church of the Nazarene, Free Will Baptist, Pentecostal Holiness, or Jehovah's Witnesses, your religion is one of the hundreds of new sects founded by men within the past 150 or so years.

     If you belong to a non or inter-denominational group, your religion was founded in the last 50 years and your interpretation of the Bible is determined by your founding pastor or left up to each individual to interpret as they like.

     All of this sounds like what St. Paul condemned in his letter to the Corinthians because one faction was saying, “I am of Paul,” i.e., follower of Paul, and another faction said, “I am of Peter”, and another, “I am of Apollo”.   St. Paul told them the Church cannot be divided into factions based on certain persons, groups or personalities.  Today people are doing the same thing saying, “I follow Luther, Joseph Smith, the Baptists, the Charismatics, Joel Osteen, or this preacher or that group or denomination.  St. Paul taught there is only one Church and all such divisions are incompatible with the one Church that Christ established.

     Another problem with sola scriptura is that it contradicts itself.  The teaching of sola scriptura is not found in the Bible, which it would have to be if your beliefs are based on the Bible alone.  

     There are numerous other problems with the idea that the Church is based on the Bible alone but I will mention only one more.  With sola scriptura you end up with confusing and contradictory versions of the Christian Faith all claiming the Bible as their support.

     Each denomination, group or individual in American Christianity can quote Bible verses to support their beliefs and show the other beliefs to be wrong.  Each group claims to follow only the Bible, to be led by the one and same Holy Spirit and to be a true expression of the Christian Faith.  Yet, there are numerous interpretations and different versions of the Faith.  American Christianity may resemble the confusion of Babel more than the unity of Pentecost.

The Foundation of the Orthodox Christian Faith
     For the Orthodox, the foundation of Scripture alone is a foundation of shifting sand that cannot be trusted and results in confusion.  It is an introduction of new and innovative teachings that creates understandings and practices that are very different from the historic Christian Faith.  

     The Orthodox Church can trace its unbroken history directly back to the Church founded by Christ and the apostles on the day of Pentecost.  This is not arrogance but a statement of historical fact that anyone can discover with a little reading.  Read A History of the Jewish People by Josephus (a Jew and non-Christian), Ecclesiastical History by the 3rd century historian Eusebius or the writings of the Apostolic Fathers (some of whom lived during the lifetime of the apostles) and you will see this to be so.  The Orthodox Church of today is the same Church as described by these early writings.   Thus, the Orthodox Church existed before there was a New Testament.  For the first one thousand years there was one Faith and one Church in the entire world.  This is the Church that has the promise of Christ, “I will build my Church and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.” Matthew 16:18

     The bishops of this Church gathered in council in the 4th century and decided which letters/books to include in the New Testament as authentic and which letters/books to exclude as unauthentic.  What were their criteria for determining this?  What was their measuring stick?  They made this decision based on something they called the Holy Tradition received from the apostles and handed down to them.  The foundation of the Orthodox Christian Faith is Holy Tradition.   It is interesting to note that American Christianity rejects Holy Tradition and most of the teachings of the very bishops who determined which books to include in the New Testament.  And they believe these bishops, whom they reject, were inspired by the Holy Spirit in determining the books of the New Testament but in error on almost everything else they taught. 

     Holy Tradition includes the Bible but is not limited to the Bible.  The New Testament was not written as a comprehensive manual and was never intended to be so.  It was never intended to be interpreted apart from the mind of the Church.  The letters of the New Testament were written by the apostles addressing particular issues in different locations but were never intended or used as a comprehensive manual until the doctrine of sola scriptura was introduced some 1500 years later.

     By Holy Tradition, the Orthodox Church means the fullness of the Christian Faith, as established by the apostles, taught and guided by the Holy Spirit, and handed down as one Faith and one Church.   Holy Tradition is the Life and Truth of the Holy Spirit in the one undivided Church.  It is not limited to a few basic ideas.  Nothing of Holy Tradition as preserved in the Orthodox Church is considered optional, unimportant, unnecessary to our salvation or open for negotiations because it is the Life of the Holy Spirit in the Church.   As we go, we will see more of what this body of truth, Holy Tradition, includes.

     Christ never wrote a book and never instructed anyone to do so.  He did, however, ordain apostles whose function and teachings were the foundation stones of the Church.  He then instructed them to make disciples by baptizing and teaching ALL that He had commanded them and by passing on the apostolic doctrine to faithful men who would be able to teach others also.  Once again, it is this Holy Tradition, the Life and Truth of the Holy Spirit in the Church as received from the apostles and passed down in its fullness and unity through each generation that is the foundation of the Orthodox Christian Faith.  It includes the Holy Scriptures, the teachings of the Fathers, Confessors, Martyrs and Saints of the Church, the canons of the Holy Councils and Synods of the Church, the Iconography, prayers and hymns of the worship services and the oral teachings that have been received and passed on from one generation to the next.  This is all in keeping with the words of St. Paul in 2 Thessalonians 2:15 that the Church is to hold fast to the apostolic traditions whether written or spoken.  So, Holy Tradition is the Way, Truth and Life of the Holy Spirit in the Church which began at Pentecost, was established and passed on by the apostles and continues to the present day in the one undivided Faith of Holy Orthodoxy.  This is the one, holy Catholic [possessing the fullness of the Faith] Church that holds the same Faith at all times and in all places from Pentecost to the end of time and into eternity.  Once again, this is the Church that Christ promised to build and to preserve.  It is His Body, His Bride.

     The Church rests upon this foundation of Holy Tradition, preserving the fullness of the apostolic Christian Faith, undivided.  Only in the context of Holy Tradition can the Bible be properly interpreted with one unified understanding since the Bible grew out of and is a part of Holy Tradition.  Without the rule of Holy Tradition the interpretation of the Bible becomes a free for all and an instrument of error and confusion.  

Different Content
     Different foundations lead to different content.  To be sure, there are some similarities in the content of what is believed by American Christianity and the Orthodox Church in regard to a few of the major doctrines but even here there are shades of differences which to the Orthodox are not unimportant and cannot be overlooked as though they don’t matter.

Content of American Christianity
     The content of the Faith of American Christianity is impossible to clearly define beyond a few basics, and even here there is not one united consensus even on the basics.  American Christianity as we have already seen, embraces numerous, conflicting and even contradictory versions, all of which are reckoned to be the Christian Faith as the following illustrates:

     The Calvinists (historically Presbyterians, Primitive and other Baptists) say that according to the Bible God has predestined certain ones to heaven and others to hell and man has no choice in the matter.  The Armenians (Methodists, Nazarenes, Free Will/General Baptists and others) say that is false since the Bible teaches that salvation is based on man’s free will.  The Church of Christ says the Bible teaches that man is saved by water baptism while Baptists and others say the Bible teaches no such thing.  Lutherans teach that baptism and Holy Communion are essential means of grace for salvation while others deny this to be so, based on the Bible.  Some baptize by sprinkling or pouring and can support it with scripture; others say this is contrary to the clear teachings of the Bible.  The Salvation Army doesn’t practice either water baptism or the Lord’s Supper, believing them to be of no importance, according to the Bible, of course.  Some say the Bible teaches that man is totally depraved and incapable of doing anything to save himself; others say the Bible teaches that man is able to cooperate with God and contribute to his salvation.  Some say that good works have nothing to do with our salvation, according to the Bible; others say man can’t be saved without good works, according to the Bible.  Some say the Bible teaches once saved, always saved or eternal security; others say this is false and contrary to the clear teachings of the Bible.  The Pentecostals believe speaking in tongues to be the sign of the baptism in the Holy Spirit, according to the Bible.  Some say the tongues spoken of in the Bible ended at the end of the age of the apostles and that what is referred to as tongues today is just emotional gibberish, based on the Bible, of course.   Some believe in present day miracles.  The group known as the Church of Christ and some Baptists say miracles ceased at the end of the New Testament era, according to the Bible.   Some teach Christ will set up his kingdom on earth when he returns, others deny such a teaching.   Some teach that Christ’s death is a substitutionary atonement, others say differently.  Some say salvation is a legal declaration of forgiveness of all sins; others believe salvation is a process of transformation. Add to this all the odd and bizarre teachings and practices of Benny Hinn, T.D. Jakes, Bill Hybles, Joel Osteen, Robert Schuller, Paula White, Prophetess Bynum, Rick Warner, Mike Murdock, the holy laughter and holy barking movements and the so-called emerging church, etc, etc. and we see there is not one clearly defined Christian Faith in American Christianity that is accepted by all as the one true Faith.  In fact, it may be that the two most commonly held beliefs in American Christianity are sola Scriptura and that there is NOT one clearly defined body of belief that can be called the one true and correct Christian Faith to the exclusion of those who disagree

Content of the Orthodox Christian Faith
      And they that gladly received his word were baptized and added to the Church. And they continued steadfastly in the apostles’ doctrine and fellowship, and in breaking of bread and in prayers.  Acts 2:41,42
 
     The foundation of the Orthodox Faith, i.e., Holy Tradition, consists of specific content and may be likened to a three-legged stool.  Each leg is essential to holding up the seat. The first leg is what we call the doctrine, dogma or teachings of the Church (the apostles’ doctrine).

     It is not within the scope of this paper to explain all the doctrines of the Orthodox Faith or to show how they differ from much of American Christianity.  Such an effort would require several volumes of books.   If anyone wants to understand these differences they can learn about them in numerous books and Internet articles.  Since American Christianity is not one unified body of truth, the extent and degree of differences will vary from one person or one group to another.  The point to be made here is that there are significant differences in many areas such as the following:
  • The meaning and significance of the doctrine of the Trinity and how it must be expressed in the life and worship of the Church
  • The doctrine of the nature of Christ and how the Incarnation relates to our salvation
  • Meaning of the fall in Eden and its consequences
  • The doctrine of sin
  • Meaning of the cross and how Christ accomplished our salvation
  • What is meant by salvation and how this is accomplished in man
  • What the Church is and its role in our salvation
  • The significance and role of the Virgin Mary and the saints in the Church
  • The relationship between the Church on earth and the Church in heaven
  • The meaning and nature of worship
  • Meaning and nature of baptism, communion, repentance, confession, absolution, marriage, the priesthood and the forgiveness of sins
  • What is involved in living the Christian life
  • The purpose, nature and goal of the Christian life

     In some of these areas there is hardly any agreement between Orthodoxy and American Christianity.  In some areas there are similarities here and there but total agreement is rare in any area.  The disagreements are significant enough to end up with two very different understandings of the Christian Faith.  This is why some in American Christianity question whether or not Orthodoxy is truly Christian.  Some question whether the Orthodox are even saved due to many Orthodox teachings they consider false, not the least of which is the rejection of the idea that people are saved or born again simply by saying a brief prayer and inviting Jesus into their hearts. (Where is this taught in the Bible?)  From the Orthodox perspective, this may be a good beginning but it is not the new birth or entrance into the Church. 

     The second leg of this three-legged stool of Holy Tradition is the worship of the Church (the apostles’ breaking of bread and of prayers). Just as God revealed one true way of worship to the Church in the Old Testament, which preserved a true understanding and worship of the one true God, the Orthodox Christian Faith holds that God has done the same in the New Testament Church.  This understanding about worship is drawn from Holy Tradition.  In particular it is found in the writings of those who succeeded the apostles in which they tell us that this is the understanding passed on to them from the apostles, the apostolic form of worship.  This understanding is also taught and confirmed in the writings of the Fathers and Confessors of the Church and the voice of the Holy Spirit in the one united Faith of the Church from the beginning to the present.  The earliest recorded description of the Church’s worship at the end of the first century is a liturgical form based on the order of Temple worship and is identical to the order still followed in the Orthodox Church today.

     The early Church continued the basic form or outline of worship God had given to Israel but substituted the reality or fulfillment of the law as fulfilled by Christ in place of the old shadows or symbols of the law under Moses.   For example, the animal sacrifices of the Temple worship are replaced by the communion of Christ’s Body and Blood in the Divine Liturgy.   The Old Testament Feast of Passover is fulfilled in the Death and Resurrection of Christ called Pascha in the Orthodox Faith and Easter in American Christianity.  The covenant of circumcision in the Old Testament is fulfilled in holy baptism in the Church.  The Sabbath of the Law is fulfilled in the Resurrection on Sunday, etc.    

     The Orthodox Faith holds that the worship of the Church is divinely revealed and cannot be changed anymore than the Bible can be changed.  The worship of the Church is another part of Holy Tradition just as is the Bible.  It is held that this divinely revealed worship is essential for preserving and participating in the true Christian Faith.  It is not merely symbolic but an other-worldly and mystical participation in the worship that continually takes place around the throne of God with the saints and angels of heaven as described in the letter to the Hebrews, chapters 8 and 9 and in The Revelation of St. John.  How could anything the Holy Spirit has revealed be optional, or how could we join in worship with those who seen to us to be rejecting what the Holy Spirit has revealed in favor of a man-made and man-centered worship?

     The fact is that the way we worship reveals what we believe.  A different kind of worship created by man presents and creates a different understanding of God, Christ, Salvation and the Church compared to the Orthodox view.  The variety of beliefs of American Christianity results in a variety of worship forms and theologies of worship.  The total disconnect of American Christianity from the Holy Tradition of the Church results in the understanding that man is free to create his own personal forms of worship that reflect his own personal beliefs about God, Christ and the Church.  Christianity is individualized and customized.  When separated from the Church, worship inevitably takes on the worldly and secular characteristics of consumerism and entertainment.   A worldly, non-believer can go to such a church and enjoy this kind of service, be entertained and feel right at home, but definitely would not feel the same in an Orthodox service.  The two forms of worship grow out of and reflect two different spirits.  One is of this world; the other is not of this world.

     These two understandings of worship reflect two different concepts of God and what is necessary to approach Him.  This is reflected even in the buildings used for worship.   The Orthodox Temple with its nave, sanctuary and holy place with holy furnishings and holy atmosphere is in sharp contrast to the theatre type of auditorium, stage, performances and entertainment venues of American Christianity.  

     The third leg of the three-legged stool of Holy Tradition is the order, structure and government of the Church (the apostles fellowship).  Once again, in contrast to American Christianity that embraces a variety of forms, structures and governments, leaving it up to the people to decide, the Orthodox have received through Holy Tradition that all of this was established by the apostles and cannot be altered because it reflects the truth of the Church.  The Church was established under the authority and life of the Holy Spirit as conveyed through the apostles and is passed on through the succession of those who succeeded the apostles, namely, the bishops of the Church.  The bishops who remain in the Orthodox Faith are seen as the conduit of the Holy Spirit (as were the apostles) who pass on the apostolic Faith in the Church through each generation and preserve it as one Faith and one Church.  The laying on of hands in ordinations, baptisms, chrismations and blessings are not merely symbolic but the actual conduit and means of preserving and passing on the life of the Holy Spirit in the Church.  The worship and holy mysteries (sacraments) of the Church are filled with the saving grace that flows from the apostles through the bishops, to the priests to the people.   Thus, the Church believes there can be no true Church without a true bishop nor can there be any grace filled sacraments.

Different Conclusions
         Different foundations lead to different content, which leads to different conclusions.  Many of the different conclusions regarding the Christian Faith have been touched upon throughout this article and are fairly self-evident.  The different conclusions may be summarized under the following two questions:

1) Is there such a thing as one true Christian Faith and one true visible Church?
     As we have seen already, American Christianity says no.  American Christianity is able to join in prayers and worship with those who hold different and conflicting beliefs because of two innovative or new ideas or teachings they have developed to help them live with the contradictions of denominations and conflicting beliefs.

     The first new teaching, called reductionism, reduces the doctrine of the church to its least common denominator as the only parts that require agreement.  There is not one clearly defined body of truth (beyond a few basics) that can be identified as the Christian Faith to the exclusion of all others.   Many feel that anything beyond a few basics such as Jesus is Lord and Savior is not required or necessary and really cannot be known for certain. Most of the teachings of the Bible are open to individual or denominational interpretations. They refuse to admit it but this is pure and simple theological relativism and reductionism that has overtaken American Christianity.  Consequently, if people profess faith in Christ, this is good enough for united prayer and worship. It doesn’t matter if one believes in predestination and one in free will, or if one believes once saved always saved and one that a Christian can backslide and be lost, or that one believes baptism saves us and one doesn’t even practice baptism.

     The problem is that the differences are not minor or unimportant.  The differences between various groups of American Christianity include doctrines of sin, salvation, the sacraments and the doctrine of the Church itself, i.e., what it is and what it isn’t.  These are all major issues that are crucial to the Christian Faith and our salvation.  Another issue for American Christianity is who decides what is minor and what is not.  It’s all left up to denominations, groups and individuals so there is not a consensus of the one Faith, once for all delivered to the saints as taught in the Bible, the very book they claim to stand on.   There is not even a consensus on what is minor and what is major. 

     The second innovation in American Christianity that allows for united prayer and worship in spite of all the different beliefs is the concept of an invisible Church.  This teaching developed as more and more denominations and groups came on the scene, all claiming to be the Church that Christ founded.  In the early years of denominations, each one did believe they possessed the one true Faith.  But eventually there was such a proliferation of contradictory beliefs that most ceased to believe in the idea of one true Faith.  Thus, the idea of the invisible Church became an essential dogma of American Christianity (a dogma, by the way, that is not found in the Bible).  This is the teaching that there is not one true visible Church on earth.  The Church exists invisibly only in the heart.  Thus, you can have all these conflicting denominations and still see them all as one because they all, in their hearts, confess faith in Christ as Lord and Savior.  This is a new concept created by American Christianity to deal with the conflicting teachings and divisions of many “churches”.   The Church, as something visible and specific, has been replaced in American Christianity by something invisible and unspecific called Christianity.  The church has come to mean basically, a building or a voluntary association of people who get together because they like the same things.  Thus, the church is more like a club than the Church.   The Christian Faith and the Church are seen as two different things.  You can get the Christian Faith sort of on your own and then it’s a good idea to join a church of your choice.   Christianity is what’s important.  The church is secondary.

     It is interesting to note that Christianity is not mentioned in the New Testament, but the Church is mentioned over 100 times. In the Acts of the Apostles and all the other Epistles there is only the CHURCH.  Anyone who believed was united to the CHURCH through baptism.  People can’t create a new Church any more than someone can create a new United States of America.  If you want to become a citizen of the USA, you don’t try to create a new one but you humbly submit to the one that is and has existed in history and abide by its laws and life.  The same is true concerning the Church. 

     In the Orthodox Faith the invisible Church is the Church triumphant – the saints in heaven.  The Church on earth is clearly visible and identifiable even as it was in the Book of Acts.  The Church is not a building but the visible Body of Christ, the New Nation or Israel of God.  And as in the Acts of the Apostles, this visible Church is still identified by those who continue in the apostles’ doctrine (one body of truth), fellowship (unity/agreement/submission to apostolic oversight), breaking of bread (celebrating one Holy Communion) and prayers (apostolic form of worship) – a unified body of truth, worship and practice. 

     The theological relativism and reductionism and the newly created dogma of the invisible Church are considered by the Orthodox to be serious betrayals of the truth as revealed by the Holy Spirit and held in the Church from the beginning.  For the Orthodox there can be only one true Christian Faith, a Faith that is denied and betrayed by a conglomeration of conflicting beliefs and practices.  What many in American Christianity never stop to consider is that their beliefs have arisen from the Western concept of democracy rather than from the history and Faith of the Church and thus reflect a secular world view rather than a view of the Church as the sacred and holy Bride of Christ that must be kept pure and faithful.

     In the Old Testament God revealed to Israel – His Church, one Faith, one government and one way of worship.  Israel was forbidden to deviate from any of this because God had attached Himself and His grace to what He had revealed.  All else was false.  There was only one truth and one way that reflected one God.  The pagan Gentiles, on the other hand, held many different beliefs, ways and worships that reflected their belief in many different gods. The Samaritans, however, retained most of the Faith of Israel and changed only a few things here and there.  Yet, when Jesus spoke to the Samaritan woman He said, “You Samaritans know not what you worship for salvation is from the Jews”.   There was no room for joint worship or prayer even though the differences were what American Christianity would call minor.  In spite of what God revealed to His Church in the Old Testament, and in spite of the fact that the first Church in Jerusalem and all the apostles were Jews and would have known nothing else, and in spite of the fact that the New Testament Church is the New Israel of God, American Christianity still rejects the belief of one Faith and one Church that is visible, definable and historical from Pentecost to the present.   They view the Church more as a sprawling ranch style house with each generation laying its own foundation and adding additional endless rooms in all directions. The Orthodox views the Church more as a skyscraper with each generation adding a new floor to the one unchanging foundation.

2) Why is unity in what we believe and practice necessary for worship and prayer? 
     For the Orthodox what we offer to God in worship and prayer must be pure and in the unity of the one Holy Spirit since we believe disunity and false teachings are contrary to the will of God and an offense to the Holy Spirit.   How can we ignore large parts of what God has revealed and established in the Church when our worship is intended to honor Him?  How can we say that much of the Bible is minor or not essential?  How can we completely ignore the voice of the Holy Spirit in the Church through history?  To pretend to be unified with one Faith and one Holy Spirit when we actually hold different faiths and different spirits is, for the Orthodox, lacking in honesty and truth, both of which are essential for approaching God.   To join in public worship and prayer with those who hold something other than or less than the fullness of Faith revealed by the Holy Spirit is to say it doesn’t matter that some have distorted, changed or modified what God has set in order in his Body, the Church.   For the Orthodox it matters not only from the point of integrity and authenticity but also for the sake of our salvation, as the following will show.

     The scriptures that teach this truth are some of those that American Christianity seems to ignore even in their zeal for what is taught in the Bible.
Romans 16:17:  Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them, which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine, which you have learned and avoid them. [Avoid in this context indicates the fellowship of worship and prayer.]
I John 4:1: Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God; because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
II John 9-11: Whosoever transgresses, and abides not in the doctrine of Christ hath not God.  He that abides in the doctrine of Christ, he hath both the Father and the Son. If there come any unto you and bring not this doctrine, receive him not into your house [into the fellowship of prayer and worship, i.e. house churches at that time], neither bid him Godspeed: For he that biddeth him Godspeed is partaker of his evil.   [Here we see that abiding in the one true apostolic doctrine and rejecting false doctrine are essential for abiding in the Holy Trinity.]
Galatians 1:8-9: But though we, or an angel from heaven, preach any other gospel unto you than that which we have preached unto you, let him be anathema [judged as outside of the kingdom of God].  As we said before, so say I now again, if any man preach any other gospel unto than that you have received, let him be anathema. [Incidentally, the Church never understood “gospel” to mean only “Jesus loves you and died for you” but rather the fullness of all that Christ taught and did.]
I Timothy 4:16: Take heed unto thyself, and unto the doctrine; continue in them; for in doing this thou shalt both save thyself, and them that hear thee. [It is essential to our salvation that we continue in the body of truth that is the Christian Faith.]
Titus 1: 7-13: A bishop must be blameless, as the steward of God…holding fast the faithful word as he has been taught, that he may be able by sound doctrine both to exhort and to convince the gainsayers. [those who hold a contrary doctrine]
Titus 2:1: But speak thou the things which become sound doctrine.
II Thessalonians 2:15: Therefore, brethren, stand fast, and hold the traditions which you have been taught, whether spoken or written. [Here he refers to the Holy Tradition of the Church – the fullness of the Faith, not just a few essentials.  This is a verse you are not likely to hear a sermon on in American Christianity.]
II Timothy 4: 2-4: [St. Paul’s instructions to the presbyter Timothy] Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine.  For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but after their own lusts shall they gather around teachers, having itching ears; and they shall turn away their ears from the truth.
Titus 3:10: A man that is an heretic, after the first and second admonition, reject.  

     There can be no concept of heresy in American Christianity, beyond a few “major” doctrines, because there is no concept of one Christian Faith.  St. Paul tells the presbyter Titus to remove from the Church anyone who holds to heresy if they refuse to repent when admonished.  The word heresy means to pick and choose, mixing truth with error, treating the Christian Faith like a smorgasbord from which you can take what you want and leave what you don’t like.  Since, in American Christianity, there is not one clearly defined body of truth or one true visible Church, the concepts of heresy and excommunication don’t exist.  All of American Christianity is, itself, a form of picking and choosing with the mixture of truth and error.  Consequently, Orthodoxy would consider it a violation of Scripture and all the Church has taught throughout the centuries to enter into a joint worship or prayer service with what the Church calls heresy.  

Summary
     American Christianity believes the Christian Faith is held in many different forms in many different groups and bodies.  The Orthodox Church believes there is one Faith that was taught by Christ to the apostles, established by the apostles in the Church and has been preserved in the Church by the Holy Spirit as one Faith, unchanged and indivisible.   For the Orthodox this Church must continue in the apostles’ doctrine, under a true bishop, with one divinely revealed way of worship and Church government.  These are the conduits through which the Holy Spirit is passed and preserved in the one Body of Christ.  While we understand that many in American Christianity hold parts of the Christian Faith and are sincerely seeking God this does not allow us to act as though the Church can be divided and the Christian Faith can consist of many conflicting parts.   We do not believe that unity can grow out of compromise or can somehow be achieved if we just pretend.  We believe that unity in the Faith is prerequisite for unity in public prayer and worship that honors God in Spirit and in Truth.

     There really are only two choices.  Either there is no such thing as one true Faith and Church, which is relativism; or there is, but no one can know or say for sure what it is, which is agnosticism.  And if there is one true Faith and Church, how can we be unified in worship and prayer and bid Godspeed to that which we see as an erroneous distortion of the ark of salvation?   We can pray for unity and seek unity among those willing to listen, but we cannot create unity where it doesn’t exist.

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Why I Don't Celebrate Christmas


Why I Don’t Celebrate Christmas
by Joseph Bragg

           
            We all know what Christmas has become in the world.  It is essentially a worldly and secular celebration of greed, consumerism, materialism and self-indulgence.  The focus is on parties – eating and drinking, decorations, buying and entertainment. More and more these self-indulgence aspects dominate, and more and more the efforts to erase all connections to anything Christian are successfully increased. 

            And each year we hear the usual lament from Christians –
                        “It’s Christmas, not Xmas”
                        “It’s Merry Christmas, not Seasons Greetings”
                        “Let’s keep Christ in Christmas”
                        “It’s St. Nicholas, not Santa Clause”
                        “Jesus is the reason for the season”
                                    And all the rest…

And so each year Christians try to salvage and retain some spiritual meaning and emphasis in the midst of the world’s takeover of Christmas.

            But let’s be brutally honest.  These efforts have failed and are failing.  They are like the last gasps of a drowning man.  The takeover of Christmas by the world has essentially been accomplished.  A few faint cries and protests here and there make no difference, no difference at all.

            Why is this so?  Why are all such efforts by Christians doomed to failure?  Could it be because the Christians who are protesting have long ago, unconsciously or not so unconsciously, become a part of and assimilated the secular worldliness and self-indulgence they are tying to protest?  How can you fix something if you are a part of the problem?  How can you protest something that is essentially what you are doing?  How can you object to something that you have embraced?  How can you reverse the greed, consumerism, materialism and self-indulgence when that is how you, too, are celebrating?  Adding some Jesus words or phrases into the mix hardly dilutes the materialistic self-indulgence that Christians, too, have embraced. 

            All the efforts of Christians and Churches to reverse the world’s takeover of Christmas – all the protests, Nativity scenes, Christmas carols, Christmas plays, cantatas and Christmas greetings – all are set square in the middle of a Christianity that is itself largely characterized by the same greed, self-indulgence, consumerism and materialism that it is protesting.

             After all, what are these Christians doing in the weeks leading up to Christmas? Shopping, getting stressed out, buying, spending, partying, self-indulging, going to see the Rockettes, the latest movie and all the rest?  Is it any wonder the protests against the secularization of Christmas rings hollow and has no effect?

            And what about the churches?  The worship and message of the churches protesting the paganism of Christmas are themselves a form of secular and self-indulgent entertainment and consumerism.  The churches, with their feel-good-affirmation-of-self “gospel” and entertainment forms of worship, bless and sanctify greed, consumerism and self-indulgence.  How can you protest that which characterizes yourself – your own beliefs and forms of worship?

            The Christians and churches of American Christianity cannot redeem Christmas from the pagan hold on it when they themselves in lifestyle, message and worship have become like unto the worldliness they are protesting.  The only answer to the world's celebration of “Christmas” is a total withdrawal from and disassociation from all its secular forms and characteristics.   In the Scriptures, both Old and New Testaments, God never tells us to try to reform the paganism that surrounds us by participating in it while throwing in some religious words and activity.  He tells us to come out from among them and be separate, to be in the world but not of the world, to be not conformed to this world, to love not the world’s lust of the flesh, lust of the eye and pride of life but to be a holy, separate and unique people of God. 

            But won’t this make us odd and weird? Won’t this deprive us of what our flesh wants?  Precisely!  But only then can we find the path to the true worship of the Incarnation of Jesus the God-Man.  We can’t retain the true Christ and the true worship of Jesus the Christ by throwing some religious words into the self-indulgent secularism of the  “Christmas” of the world.

            The true Christ and the true worship of Christ is not found in the world’s materialistic self-indulgence nor in the “sanctified” materialistic self-indulgence of Western Christianity.  It is found only in the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church of Christ which Christ founded and which still exists today holding the same unchanged message and worship separate from and uniquely different from the spirit of this world.  In the Church we celebrate and worship the Feast of the Holy Nativity of Christ God.  But the feast is preceded by four weeks of fasting, prayer and self-denial.  The celebration comes only on the Feast Day and then lasts for the Twelve Days of Christmas until the Feast of Theophany – the manifestation of Jesus as God in His Baptism at the Jordan. 

            The world has its “Christmas”.  The Church has its Feast of the Holy Nativity. They are two completely different approaches and conclusions.  In the Church, the true worship of the Incarnation has never been lost and doesn’t need to be reclaimed.  This is why I celebrate the Nativity of Christ in the Church and not the “Christmas” of the world.  I need to be redeemed from my greed and self-indulgence by the true Christ and Saviour, not confirmed in it by a pseudo Christmas.

           


     

Sunday, December 19, 2010

The Message And The Medium


THE MESSAGE AND THE MEDIUM
How the Knowledge of the One True God and the One True Faith Are Preserved in the Government, Life and Worship of the Church

     The Church, in keeping with the clear message of the Bible, has always taught that there is a clear line of distinction between the ways, mediums,  forms and fashions of this fallen world and the Kingdom of God.  The one is the product of fallen and sinful human nature, the other a revelation of the one true God and the one true Faith for the salvation of mankind.  They represent two opposing spirits and objectives.  For according to Scripture, the flesh struggles against the Spirit and the Spirit against the flesh, and these are contrary one to the other.  They are incompatible and irreconcilable because they arise from two different sources and serve two different purposes.

     We see this already in the Old Testament in the life of Israel, the Church of the Old Testament.  Beginning with God’s call of Abraham there was a clear directive to get out from and leave his kindred – his pagan surroundings, in pursuit of the kingdom that God would reveal.  This kingdom, in every way would stand in clear distinction from the kingdom of this world that knows not God.  It would represent a different world and different way of life.  God didn’t tell Abraham to simply introduce the new into the midst of the old but to leave the old order and ways in order to embrace the kingdom or rule of God over His people.

     As you follow the history of Israel from the Exodus to Canaan there is a clear directive from God that His people are to disassociate themselves from pagan forms and ways in favor of that which God would reveal and institute for His people.  They were always to “come out from among them and be ye separate”.  The promises to Israel from God were always that He would be their God, their provider and protector, IF they would flee all expressions and associations with a pagan society and pagan forms of worship in favor of the kingdom that God would reveal to them – a sacred and holy nation sanctified or set apart unto the Lord and in no way identified with the fallen and sinful world from which they were being rescued. 

      When God led Israel in conquest over the pagan lands, the instructions were clear.  They were not to borrow things and ways from the pagan people nor could they intermarry or participate in any way with the pagan forms of worship.   All pagan forms and expressions were to be destroyed.  God revealed and instituted something totally different and sacred in the way they were to live, eat, be governed and worship.  The message was that the Kingdom of God was to be distinct and in no way reflective of the fallen world and paganism around them because the God they worshipped was in no way like the pagan gods.

     This same message is applied to the Church of the New Testament.  The Saviour called on those who would follow Him to understand the clear distinction and break with the fallen world.  The way to heaven, He taught, is straight and narrow and there are few who find it, while the way to death is wide and broad and many go in thereat.

     The Apostle John taught us to “Love not the world neither the things that are in the world.  For all that is in the world, the lust of the flesh, the lust of eyes and the pride of life is not of the Father but is of the world, and the world passeth away and the lusts thereof, but he who does the will of the Father abides forever.”  Saint Paul taught that we are to “Be not conformed to this world but be ye transformed by the renewing of your mind.”

The Church is the New Israel in whom the Blessing of Abraham is fulfilled through faith in Christ.  Thus Saint Peter applies the words spoken to Israel of old to the Body of Christ, the Church: “But you are a chosen generation, a holy nation, a royal priesthood, a peculiar people that you may show forth the praises of Him Who called you out of darkness into His marvelous light.” 

The same theme continues through all the Gospels, the Epistles and into the Revelation of Saint John.  This world, with all its fallenness will pass away, but the new order of God’s Kingdom will abide forever.  The Kingdom of Heaven will not be a mixture of the old and the new but the old will be consumed by fire and all things will be new.  The Church is already a foretaste of this reality and therefore must not intermingle the ways of the world.

The Church understands herself to be the Bride of Christ, a pilgrim and stranger for whom this world is not her home.  She lives and moves and has her being in a new kingdom that is uniquely sacred and distinct from this world.   She is the New Israel of God.  Thus, the Church, as the “called out ones” (meaning of ecclesia from which we get the word Church) is to reflect the newness and distinctiveness of the Kingdom of Heaven as a witness to the one true God and the one true Faith.

In view of all of this, along with the Church’s self understanding as the Body of Christ, the Church draws a clear distinction between that which proceeds from and fulfills the desires of this fallen world and that which is sacred and holy and proceeds from the Holy Spirit in the Kingdom of God. 

This results in a clear line of distinction in several crucial areas of the life of the Church.  In all these areas, the Church understands her faith and life to be divinely given and revealed and therefore not open for negotiations.  The Church believes that the Holy Spirit was given to the Church, just as Christ promised, to guide her into all truth.  Therefore, that which the apostles established and passed on to their successors is given by the Holy Spirit as surely as the Holy Scriptures themselves.

First, as regards the government of the Church, the Church follows the apostolic form of government, i.e., the order and structure established by the apostles; namely, that Christ is the head of the Church, the absolute sovereign, while the oversight and shepherding of the Church on earth is committed to bishops, the icons of Christ and successors to the apostles, who are served by presbyters and deacons.  These, together with the laity, gathered around and drawing its life from the Eucharist (the Body and Blood of Christ), form the Body of Christ.  In this way the very structure of the Church reflects the Holy Trinity and the unity of the Faith.

This government is distinct from the kingdoms of this world.  The Church does not follow the patterns or forms or mediums of the governments of this world that are the products of and serve to fulfill the desires of fallen human nature, such as dictatorships, the papacy, congregational rule, popular vote, anarchy, or majority rule.  The Church is not a democracy but a theocracy.   Again, there is a clear line of distinction between the mediums of the world and the sacredness and holiness of the Church and her message that reveals the one true God and the one true Faith.

Second, as regards the life of the Church, there is also a clear line of distinction between that which defines society and that which defines the Body of Christ.   The heartbeat of society is generally geared towards consumerism, secularism, materialism and entertainment.  Its main focus is on self-indulgence – the worship of self.  Even its “Christian” holidays are mainly a devotion to self-indulgence and entertainment.

But the Church marches to the beat of a different drum – by that which is sacred, holy and otherworldly in sharp contrast to that which is secular, materialistic and earthly.  The Church calls us to lose ourselves, as regards this world, in order to find ourselves in the Kingdom of God.  The Church has her own calendar, her feasts and fasts and holy days.  Remembrances such as Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Valentine’s Day, May Day, Arbor Day, President’s Day, Independence Day and the like are not a part of the calendar and observances of the worship and life of the Church.   They belong to the kingdoms of this world. 

The Church has her own unique way of life that goes beyond the calendar, feasts and fasts and includes clear and absolute teachings on morality, appropriate lifestyles and manner of dress both for clergy and laity.  Not merely for the sake of following rules or being moralistic but for the sake of bearing witness to the true nature of God and the true nature of the Kingdom of God.

Third, as regards the teachings or dogmas of the Church, she follows the apostolic doctrine.  The Church does not look to the intellect of divinity schools or the latest fads in the latest books by the latest gurus, educators or pop icons.  All of these, she sees as reflections of a fallen world and out of touch with the life and spirit of the Church.  Her doctrine does not change or develop with time, nor is it ever subjected to vote, popular opinion or faddishness.   The understanding of truth as relative has no place in the dogma of the Church.  Her dogma is not derived from nor does it reflect the views of popular psychology, political correctness or current religious understanding in the world, which are alien to the life and spirit of the Church.  Her teachings are held to be Divinely given and revealed, once and for all.  The strict and careful stance of the Church regarding her dogmas is for the sake of preserving a true understanding of God and of the Faith of Christ, for it is by this that we must be saved.

Fourth, the same is true as regards the worship of the Church.  As with her government, way of life and doctrine, the Church holds that her worship has been divinely given by the Holy Spirit for the preservation of the true Faith.

Her Divine Services come from the very forms of worship that God revealed to His Old Testament Church but now reflect the New Covenant and the fulfillment and realities of the old types and shadows.  This was the way of worship adopted by the early Church as established by the apostles, and as witnessed to in the writings of those who succeeded the apostles.  The New Testament Church knew no other form of worship other than that which God had revealed.  It was unthinkable that just any form or any way could be appropriate for the worship of God.  The worship of the Church had to be divinely revealed and true to God’s nature and the Holy Faith.

The forms of worship for Israel were not optional.  It was not left to personal likes nor could it be a mixture of the paganism that surrounded them.  The worship of God’s chosen people had to be pure and had to reflect the true and sacred nature of the one true God and the one true Faith He had revealed.

As with Israel, the hymnbook of the Church is the Psalter.  Additional hymns have been written by the saints whose faithfulness to the truth of the Church and whose humility and holiness have borne witness to their God-bearing lives.  It was unthinkable that just anyone who had not attained to purity in the Church could provide her music.  It must come from a mind and heart deeply saturated with the life and spirit of the Church. 

Again, as with Israel, the language of worship in the Church is the chant.  This has been revealed to certain saints by divine revelation as the way the saints and angels worship at the throne of God in heaven.  The Church understands that the worship revealed to Israel and that which she now follows, was given as an earthly pattern of the heavenly worship.  Since the Church in heaven and the Church on earth are one, they must worship in the same Spirit and the same truth.  The book of Hebrews (chapter 9) talks about this very fact, that the earthly worship of the Church is a pattern of the heavenly worship.  The worship described in the Revelation of Saint John, reveals the same idea as regards the worship of the saints and angels before the throne of God, complete with hymns and incense that are still used in the Divine Liturgy of the Church.

In addition to the above, there are several other crucial characteristics of the worship of the Church that draw a clear distinction between it and the ideas of contemporary “Christian” music and worship.

First, the worship of the Church is not a form of entertainment nor does it draw from the entertainment venues of the world.  Good entertainment is fine in its place but the worship of the Church is not entertainment nor should it resemble entertainment.  The worship of the Church must always lift us out of this world into the Kingdom of Heaven.  It is a sacred and holy work intended to manifest and worship the one true God and the one true faith He has revealed.

Contemporary “Christian” music and worship uses the forms, mediums and venues of worldly entertainment.  It reflects the nature of entertainment, i.e. the Lawrence Welk Show, the Boston Pops Symphony, the Grand Ole Opry, Disneyland, etc. more than it reflects the nature of God and the nature of the Christian Faith. Contemporary ideas intend to bring God down to man’s level.  The historic worship of the Church intends to lift man up to God.  Therefore it does not reflect the earthly but rather the Kingdom of Heaven.

Second, the worship of the Church, not only does not use entertainment venues which may not be evil within themselves, but especially does not use or adopt forms, mediums and venues from the world that clearly grow out of man’s fallen and depraved passions and senses and exist to satisfy and fulfill those same fallen passions and senses.   The ideas of “Christian Rock” and “Christian Rap” are completely inconceivable in Orthodox worship.  Forms and mediums such as these grew out of pagan worship and/or devotion to the gratification of the sensual and human vanity.  They appeal to and entertain the emotions of our fallen and depraved passions. 

In the world of consumer religion, many today cannot distinguish between being “blessed by the spirit” and having their fallen passions entertained.  The true distinction between the flesh and the Spirit as set forth by the Holy Fathers is unknown in contemporary “Christianity”.  Today, the distinction between that which is of the Spirit and that which is of the flesh is confused and intermingled.  Many feel that the use of “Christian” words alone make the contemporary forms “spiritual” but fail to reckon how the medium conveys a message and influence of its own.

The entertainment venues of the world, even when words about Christ are substituted for other words, still glorify a certain materialistic vanity and sensuality in dress and lifestyle that is completely incompatible with the ascetical struggle of the Christian that strives for union with Christ through holiness, humility and self-denial.  Even the words of contemporary “Christian” music reflect an understanding of the Christian Faith that is very different from the historic Christian Faith, the Faith of the Saints and the Fathers.

 That which has grown out of man’s sinful nature for the purpose of satisfying that nature cannot be an appropriate medium for comprehending the true nature of God and the true nature of the Church and her Faith.  Whatever such mediums produce, it will bear little resemblance to the historic Christian Faith.

In the Church, it is inconceivable that unbelievers, or unregenerate people who are given to worldly and carnal lifestyles could walk into a worship service of the Church, feel comfortable and enjoy it as they would enjoy a Vegas show.  However, this is common in contemporary worship and music. It reveals that these forms speak to and satisfy the fallen emotions and passions.  It is also inconceivable that an unbeliever or unregenerate person would “enjoy” a Divine Liturgy in an Orthodox Church as an enjoyable form of entertainment.  They may find it interesting or sense something sacred and different about it or even be repelled by it, but they will not enjoy it as a good show or entertaining event. 

The early Church did not even allow unbelievers to attend their worship services.  Still today, there is a point in the service, before the liturgy of the Eucharist, when those who are not baptized are supposed to depart from the service.  This shows how different the contemporary understanding of worship is from that of the historical Christian Faith.  In the Acts of the Apostles we read that the unbelievers “dared not join themselves” to the worship of the believers.   

Third, the worship of the Church must be in spirit and in truth.  In “spirit” has a twofold meaning.  It means in sincerity and not half-heartedly.  But it also means in the Holy Spirit.  The Church believes there is one Holy Spirit from the time of Israel to the present.  The worship of the Church must be in harmony with and according to that which the Holy Spirit has revealed and not that which the fallen and carnal world has produced.  This results in worship that is also in truth – it reveals and participates in the truth of the one true God and the truth of the one true faith. 

Thus, the music and worship of the Church is clearly distinguished from the music and entertainment of the world.  One is of the earth, earthy.  The other is of heaven, heavenly.  One appeals to and satisfies the “feel good” emotions of the flesh, while the other appeals to one who is trying to crucify his fleshly emotions and passions to acquire the Holy Spirit..  The one speaks to the spirit of this age, the other speaks to the Spirit of life in the Kingdom of God.  

Thus, the government, life, dogma and worship of the Church are not in any way derived from the ideas, venues or mediums of this world.  There is a clear line of distinction between the mediums and venues of the world and the life and worship of the Church for the preservation of the knowledge of the one true faith and the worship of the one true God.

joseph bragg

Sunday, December 5, 2010

DO YOU BELIEVE IN GOD?

I saw a site trying to get 5 million people to click saying they believe in God.  I raised the question could the Devil vote since he, too, believes in God? (St James 2:19).  Someone responded that yes he could vote but he would tremble as he did, again see St. James 2:19.   Later I added : So, if the devil's vote will count that means that many others could vote who have the same kind of belief in God as the devil. So in the end what does the vote accomplish since everyone has their own beliefs and ideas about God according to their own likes and desires. Millions of Muslims, Buddhists and Jews could also vote that they believe in God. Millions of "Christians" also have myriads of conflicting understandings about God, some true and some false. Should that make us happy just that they say they believe in God? Perhaps the results would be more meaningful if the survey is to "click" if you believe in the One True God who said "beside me there is no other" and Who has come to us in the flesh of the Blessed Virgin Mary, the Only Begotten Son of God who lives and reigns in His Body, the Church. To merely say "I believe in God" means little or nothing in a pluralistic and post-Christian society.

Christmas And The Rockettes

Could someone explain to me the relationship between dancing half naked sexually provocative women, called The Rockettes, and the celebration of the Nativity of the Most Holy Son of God? Every year many, including professing Christians, flock to this as a part of the celebration of Christmas, many of whom don't even attend a worship service on the day of the Feast.  Many churches don't even have such a service!

 Do we really prepare to meet the coming Saviour with the Rockettes? The Saviour taught us to prepare for His Advent with holy vigilance, prayer, repentance, fasting and self-denial?

It seems to me that the Rockettes are the quintessential example of a pagan celebration of the world that still uses the name Christmas as an excuse to indulge the gods of entertainment and materialism.

Sunday, October 24, 2010

Holy Week at the Monastery


HOLY WEEK AT THE MONASTERY

For those curious to know, the following is an account of Holy Week which I recently  (written in 2006) spent at Holy Transfiguration Monastery, Boston, MA.  The services at the monastery are the same services held in parishes during Holy Week.  A few of them are an hour or so longer than they may be in most parishes.  There are no pews, only benches along the wall.  The idea is to stand for all the services if possible since the services are seen as a labor of love and sacrifice to God.

The monastery building is an old mansion built in 1881 by the Schlesinger family as their home.  They were a wealthy steel family in Boston.  (Arthur Schlesinger, a descendent, was secretary of defense under Richard Nixon.)

The building has some 70 rooms with lots of thick oak doors, paneling and elaborate carvings.  It feels like and resembles an old castle.  They paid $400,000.00 for it in 1970.  It has 20 acres with woods, a creek and a cemetery.  The monks have goats, a green house for growing herbs, paint icons, make incense and publish books to earn a living.

There are some 40 monks at the monastery ranging in age from the 20’s to the 70’s and maybe one or two in their 80’s.  They are from several different nationalities and countries and come from backgrounds in most major Protestant denominations, Roman Catholicism, Anglicanism and various independent and charismatic movements including Oral Roberts University (including two former professors).  It is quite an eclectic group.

I arrived on Holy Wednesday of Holy Week.  They had already had two days of special services that began on Palm Sunday evening and continued on Holy Monday and Holy Tuesday.

The abbot of the monastery, Fr. Isaac, picked me up at the airport and we arrived at the monastery at 12:45, just in time for the 1:00 Pre-Sanctified Liturgy. It is called by this name because the Bread and Wine used for the Eucharist are pre-sanctified on Sunday for use during the weekday liturgies to maintain a penitential mood during the week.  Sundays always celebrate the Resurrection and thus the Bread and Wine are sanctified on that day.

Since the Eucharist must always be preceded by fasting, the monks had not eaten since the day before.  The Pre-Sanctified Liturgy ended at 3:00 PM.

We then had lunch, the only meal of the day, in keeping with the Lenten Fast.  It consisted of vegetable soup that had red beans, macaroni, squash, zucchini, carrots, onions, peas, celery and potatoes.  For dessert there was strawberry sorbet, a banana, fresh olives, bread and water. The Lenten Fast (not just for monks but all Orthodox Christians) is essentially eating without meat, wine, olive oil, dairy and eggs for 8 weeks.  Fish is permitted only on a few days during the fast.

 During meals at the monastery, there is no talking and one of the monks stands and reads from some spiritual writings while everyone eats. After we ate, everyone had an assigned clean up duty.  In about 20 minutes we had the tables cleared, the dishes in the dishwasher, the left over food put away and the tables completely reset and ready for the next meal.  (The abbot told me they spend about $1,000.00 per week at the market even without the purchase of meat, since they never eat meat).

I then road with Fr. Sergios, one of the monks, to deliver some fasting food to a family who owes a Pizza/Sub shop in town and are close friends of the monastery. This was so they could keep the Lenten fast while working.

From 6:30-9:00 PM we had the service of Holy Unction, which always falls on Holy Wednesday.  This is a service that includes anointing with Holy Oil blessed by the bishop for the healing of soul and body.  Incidentally, the bishop resides at this monastery.

I slept in a guest room with two other guests.  One was an 84-year-old retired businessman who comes often just to visit.  He was from upstate New York.  The other guest was Sergei from St. Petersburg, Russia.  He is a portrait painter who gets commissioned by wealthy families in America to come and paint their family portrait.  He was in town on business but was able to participate in most of the services of Holy Week.  There were several other guests staying in another guest room, all young men whose wives were staying at the convent that is just five minutes away.  They were all recent converts to Orthodoxy from various backgrounds.

On Holy Thursday morning, the Abbot assigned me to help with the dying of eggs in the kitchen at 7:30 AM .  We dyed red some 1,000 boiled eggs which the monks give away and eat during the 40 days of Pascha (more on this later) until the Feast of the Ascension.

The next service was a Hierarchical Divine Liturgy from 11:30 AM till 3:00 PM.  It is called hierarchical because a hierarch, the bishop, presides and celebrates this liturgy.  This liturgy commemorates the institution of the Eucharist by the Savior on Thursday of Holy Week.

After this liturgy, we had the only meal of the day, which consisted of boiled potatoes, slaw with vinegar dressing, grapes, olives, sugar cookies, bread, water and wine.  On Holy Thursday, wine is permitted during the Lenten Fast since this day is the commemoration of the institution of the Lord’s Supper.  This was the last meal we would have until Saturday afternoon.

On Holy Thursday evening we had the Service of the Twelve Passion Gospels, which lasted from 7:00 PM till Midnight.  This service consists of many prayers and hymns interspersed between 12 readings taken from the four Gospels describing all the events leading up to the betrayal of Christ, the Crucifixion, the Burial and the events that followed except for the Resurrection.

During this service the icon of the body of Christ is placed on a cross that stands front and center and the faithful prostrate themselves before the cross.

Incidentally, in the chapel, there are no electric lights.  The only lights are oil lamps and candles.

On Great and Holy Friday the service began at 10:00 AM and ended at 3:30 PM.  This consists of several services put together: The Royal Hours, Vespers, Pre-Sanctified Liturgy and the taking down from the cross service.  During this time the body of Christ is removed from the Cross, wrapped in linen cloth and taken in procession as to the tomb which has been prepared before hand and now sits in the front of the temple.  Here the image of the body of Christ is adorned with flowers, spices and myrrh in imitation of the burial preparation by the myrrh-bearing women as described in the Holy Gospels.  All the faithful then come and prostrate themselves before the tomb and worship His Holy Suffering and Death.

On Holy Friday evening we had the Service of Lamentations which lasted from 7:00 PM till 11:00 PM.  During this service we gather around the tomb and sing hymns of lamentations, which are hymns of repentance and of praise for the Savior’s love, suffering, and death.  I attended this service with the nuns at the convert just down the street from the monastery.

On Holy Saturday morning there was another Hierarchical Liturgy with the bishop.  This lasted from 11:30 AM till 3:00 PM.  This is a solemn service in awareness that during this time the Savior was in the tomb and descended into Hades (the realm of death where all went who died before the Advent of Christ) and proclaimed his Resurrection to all those who had fallen asleep prior to his coming.  Those who embraced Him in Faith were led from the captivity of the grave into Paradise with the thief who had been crucified with Him on Holy Friday.

After this service we had our first meal since Holy Thursday.  It consisted of Tofu Soup w/pasta shells, ½ of an avocado, a banana, dates, figs, an orange, bread and water.  This was followed by the usual clean up.

Immediately after this meal the spirit of the anticipated Feast of the Resurrection begins to fill the air.  All the monks get busy cleaning the building, washing windows, preparing many floral arrangements and cleaning all the holy vessels and utensils used in all the services.

Then on Saturday evening at 11:30 PM we gathered to celebrate the Feast of the Resurrection, a joyous and festive service that lasted until 4:00 AM.  From this time until the Feast of the Ascension forty days later, the Resurrection hymns are song every week in every service and the customary greetings of “hello,” “good morning,” etc. are replaced for 40 days with the greeting of “Christ is Risen!” and the response, “Truly He is Risen!” 

This service was followed by a light meal which breaks the fast and consisted of fish soup, feta cheese, Pascha bread and Pascha cheese, an orange, chocolates, wine, coffee and water.  (In the Orthodox Church Easter is called Pascha, which means Passover since the death and resurrection of Christ are the fulfillment of the meaning of the Old Testament Feast of Passover.)

We went to bed at 5:00 AM and gathered again at noon for the main Pasha meal which consisted of baked cod, green beans almandine, boiled egg, an orange, Pascha bread and cheese, chocolates, wine and coffee.

Agape Vespers were chanted from 6 till 7 PM.  During this service the Resurrection Gospel is chanted in many different languages to emphasis the universality of the Gospel.  At the monastery it was done in 12 different languages.  This was followed by the evening meal, which I didn’t attend due to a phone call about Nathan’s arrest.

The week following Pascha is called Bright Week and there are services everyday to celebrate the Resurrection.  We had the liturgy for Bright Monday from 7 till 10 AM. 

This was followed by lunch which consisted of baked fish filet, baked potato with butter, chives and sour cream, a pear, boiled egg, Pascha bread and cheese, chocolates, cookies, wine and coffee.

Monday evening I flew home to Nashville.


Joseph Bragg